Testing Beauty Pie Makeup: Part 2

Another month, another haul! As I said in my last Beauty Pie testing post, this month I was going to focus on the lips. I also wanted to include eyes, but my Beauty Pie £150 budget wouldn’t stretch that far!

I didn’t get as much for my £150 limit. I only spent £20, but the items were worth a lot more so the budget instilled on me by Beauty Pie only allowed for 5 items. Due to this, I mainly focused on lipsticks because these are what I get a lot of use out of. I only like to use 1 or 2 mascaras at a time, so it’d be a while before I got round to testing the ones in this order!

Super Luminous Concealer in the shade 100 (Pink undertone) RRP £22.00, brought for £2.69 – I am so picky when it comes to the concealers I wear; I pretty much hate every one I buy except from my Urban Decay Naked Skin Concealer and the Maybelline Age Rewind concealer. I am quite self-conscious about the bags under my eyes and the fine lines starting to appear, so I like to be quite picky about what I wear under my eyes so I don’t enhance these features. Similar to my Maybelline one, this concealer comes with a sponge to apply which I’m not the biggest fan of (unsanitary!) but I was quite surprised with the product overall. It was more liquid that I expected it to be so I assumed it would be quite a light coverage, but surprisingly it was rather full coverage! Only a small bit was applied, but it covered my entire under eye and cheek area! When patted in with a damp sponge it set very well and looked great, but there was a tiny bit of creasing after a while, despite being set with a powder. It was over the course of the day, so would need touching up after a few hours, but wore well in the process. I don’t usually go for pink undertones as I need a more yellow base to suit my skin colour, but this was a fairly good match, and incredibly brightening.

Future Lipstick Matte in the shade Power Up Pink (RRP £20.00, brought for £2.30) – I tend to float between matte and satin lipsticks depending on my mood, so I brought one of each to try. Power Up Pink is a beautiful coral fuchsia shade that is so perfect for the summer months! The formula really does remind me of MAC lipsticks; they glide on silky smooth, opaque in one swipe and last a hell of a long time. It also wore quire evenly throughout the day; I did need to touch up around mid afternoon, but I wasn’t left with a funny lip line for an uneven wear. There’s also quite a shade range for the lipsticks that is lacking in their other ranges, so something to suit everyone’s taste.

Future Lipstick Satin in the Shade Knockout Punch (RRP £20.00, brought for £3.07) – I tend to prefer satin lipsticks as they are more forgiving on the lips, so I was more interested in seeing how this formula compares to some of my favourites. The shade is a typical “my lips but better”; a rosy pink with brown undertones, and I have to say I love it! The colour is perfect for everyday use, it wears brilliantly on the lips and feels so comfortable to wear. I brought a lip liner to go with it, but you could get away with not using one too.

Moisture Lock Wondergel Lip Liner in the shades Love Nest and Rummy Pink ( RRP £15.00 each, brought for £1.50 each) – I find it very difficult to get excited about a lip liner, because they aren’t something I tend to buy unless I absolutely have to. Because of this I don’t have a lot to compare these to, but I found the Beauty Pie formulas to be creamy and pigmented; they were easy to apply and didn’t feather at all! Rummy Pink is a gorgeous nude shade very similar to Charlotte Tilbury’s Pillow Talk, whilst Love Nest is a bright fuchsia pink. They also perfectly matched the lipsticks I brought, too.

Overall, this second haul was just as impressive as the first in terms of quality, and they are all products that will get a lot of use. One thing I have noticed about Beauty Pie is the lack of shades in some ranges, but the lip based products are varied and plentiful. I would like to see some swatches on their website, as sometimes it can be a little play-by-ear in terms of finding a perfect match – it isn’t always easy to see which shade would suit my skin tone from the pictures – but this may come at a later stage as the range expands.

I’m not sure about the £150 budget you are given; this equates to the total cost of the RRP value of products, which can sometimes only allow 4 items. Maybe if the budget was £175 or £200 it would be worth committing to long-term. I do think that it is worth paying the subscription fee for access to such affordable and high quality makeup, though, and I am absolutely looking forward to testing their skin care products out next month!


Posted by

Teacher by day, beauty and lifestyle blogger by night. Wallflower, Pinterest obsessive, bookworm, baker, geek, undomesticated goddess, mother, hoarder | PR Friendly

Leave a Reply